“My Current Solar Stock Recommendation” Navellier

By Travis Johnson, Stock Gumshoe, April 23, 2008

I’m not entirely sure when this ad was sent out, or exactly what the context was, but I was sent a snippet of it from a reader just recently and thought I’d share.

The ad is for Blue Chip Growth, Louis Navellier’s large cap growth newsletter (according to Hulbert’s calculations, this newsletter has handily beaten the market over the past 3, 5 and ten year periods, though it’s worth noting that it usually carries a very large number of individual stocks in its portfolio … so individual subscribers might not match those returns).

Here’s the little snippet that was sent to me:

“An interesting thing happened to my current solar stock recommendation. Even though the company’s profits rose more than 11-fold to 15 cents per share, analysts still weren’t happy. They expected earnings of 35 cents per share! Are you kidding me? Honestly, if Wall Street had been a bit more realistic about what we can all expect, then on Thursday they would have been celebrating this company’s success, instead the stock took a small hit to its ego. I think it’s only a matter of time before Wall Street comes to its senses and realizes that when a company not only reports that its first-quarter revenue increased 92%, as well as raises its second-quarter and full-year guidance, then that stock’s on fire. Check out my Blue Chip Growth newsletter to get the name and full buy advice on this solar stock!”

So … not exactly a bucket full of clues, but, the Sun God be praised, the Thinkolator is on the case … this stock pretty well has to be …

SunPower (SPWR)

Remember when this company seemed like kind of a flaky side project investment for T.J. Rodgers, CEO and founder of Cypress Semiconductor? i guess that ages me a bit, SunPower has been the engine behind Cypress’ stock for several years, and Cypress still owns more than half of the shares (which is reflected in the market caps — CY has a market cap of about $4 billion, SPWR about $7 billion. Almost all of CY’s market cap can be explained by it’s ~52% stake in SPWR).

As with many solar stocks, SPWR is right in the middle of a sort of inflection point on earnings — we’re now at the point where solar stocks are expected to be profitable, and possibly even reasonably valued as solar energy comes closer to parity (thanks to subsidies) with the electric grid, and big government incentives continue to increase demand for “green” energy and spur installation growth. That is reflected in the fact that SPWR has a trailing PE well into the 300s, but a forward PE of only 26.

SPWR did report 15 cents a share of earnings just last week, which was lower than some analyst estimates (though the average estimate I saw was not quite so dramatic as Navellier’s tease indicates), and they did grow revenues by 92% last quarter. The outlook was somewhat conservative, which is probably why the shares tailed off a bit after the announcement, but it also could have certainly just been profit taking — the shares had almost doubled in the previous month. Navellier’s recommendations are quantitatively derived, with a big emphasis on earnings growth and momentum, and this stock does get an “A” grade in his system.

There’s a pretty good article about the earnings, with some detail and with explanation of the stock movement, here from the Mercury News if you’re interested.

SPWR and Suntech Power (STP) have been the standard-bearers for solar power in recent years — SunPower because it has had the most efficient cells, STP because it had the lowest costs. That may well be changing gradually as relative upstarts like FirstSolar, the thin film solar developers, and the lower cost Chinese companies try to build market share. Still, the market is growing so quickly that there’s something to be said for owing the big dogs who have the clearest accounting and a strong product track record like SunPower.

I have no idea who’s going to win the solar wars, and in fact I sold my only related company a few weeks ago (MEMC Electronic Materials, sold for personal portfolio reasons, not because of any immediately bad prognosis I see for the company), but I would probably be more comfortable with SPWR than with some of the smaller or more highly-valued companies in the sector. And truth be told, since Cypress is likely to track with SPWR at a lower valuation until the rest of their SPWR position is spun off, I’d probably buy CY before SPWR (that’s assuming that the underlying semiconductor business has some value, a position the market in general doesn’t seem to accept at the moment). CY has gotten some recent tax decisions that make a spinoff of the rest of SPWR to shareholders likely at some point, though I don’t know that a timetable has been set.

Everyone, it seems, has an opinion on solar stocks — I know Jim Cramer yells at anyone who suggests a purchase of anything other than First Solar … and several touts have picked SunPower in the past year, including Andrew Gordon for a 50% gain if held until now. Navellier also picked SPWR earlier this year, at closer to $120, so that pick has a 25% haircut at the moment.

But it’s your money — what’s your call?

[poll=4]

Related Gumshoe Articles

More “Monster Growth” Ideas teased by Blue Chip Growth

What are some more Navellier-teased ideas?

9 Comments Read More

Navellier’s Top Stocks for the “Goldilocks Economy”

What's being teased for Navellier's Blue Chip Growth?

9 Comments Read More

Leave a Reply

13 Comments on "“My Current Solar Stock Recommendation” Navellier"

avatar

Woman with Portfolio
Guest
0
April 23, 2008 2:36 pm

He may well have been referring to SPWR in his teaser, re the recent earnings report, but FSLR is a much better prospect if you’re looking at U.S. solar heavyweights. And he has touted FSLR in the past. Don’t have time right now to elaborate, but will later.

Gravity Switch
Admin
11
April 23, 2008 3:54 pm
Thanks WWP — FSLR is certainly even more popular, and larger. Though at that valuation they better continue growing sales at way better than SPWR’s 92% (last quarter sales for FSLR was near 300% growth, earnings 600%). FSLR is three or four times the market cap of STP and SPWR, and the valuation scares me, but it is certainly one of the few consistent high momentum growth stories in the market right now. It has gotten to this point because of the lower cost technology they use that doesn’t rely on polysilicon, prices of which have gone through the roof.… Read more »
Woman with Portfolio
Guest
0
April 23, 2008 6:11 pm
Gumshoe, sorry for the earlier hit and run. Your analysis, as usual, is clear, reasoned and very smart. And of course you hit on the crucial element of FSLR’s growth — its thin film technology that doesn’t depend on silicon. But I do agree with you that it’s at the scary stage of valuation. I wouldn’t recommend buying it myself. What’s really scary to me, though, is SPWR’s balance sheet, the insider selling and the shortsters that are on it. FSLR is the better of two iffy propositions. I don’t own either. I still have some shares of STP, which… Read more »
Gravity Switch
Admin
11
April 23, 2008 8:16 pm
Thanks for the additional comments, WWP — all good points. I suspect that the short position is betting on a significant overhang of supply if and when CY spins off the rest of their SPWR holdings, but it could just be a valuation bet — those shares did climb awfully fast, and there is always some fear that the solar stocks could collapse, at least for a time, for political reasons (failure to extend tax breaks or pass new ones, either in the US or Europe). I haven’t looked at the insider selling, though I’m always less worried about that… Read more »
Jackie
Guest
0
Jackie
April 24, 2008 9:45 am

I am buy Cypress that is for sure.
Regards
Jackie

Patrick
Guest
0
Patrick
April 24, 2008 11:08 am

Nanosolar, which isn’t publicly traded, seem to have a fundamental technological edge in terms of cost and panel throughput/efficiency.

singh
Guest
0
April 25, 2008 6:03 am

DSTI agreement with JUWI Solar maybe bad for FSLR. They supply to them now

Hawki
Guest
0
Hawki
April 26, 2008 4:27 pm

I am new to this site but already like it. I have been looking at solar … recently and happened across a company that is just starting out: AVA Solar
I would like to take advantage of this site and ask if anybody has heard good things and if so if they offer stock.

Myron Martin
Guest
0
Myron Martin
April 27, 2008 9:06 pm

Speaking of solar stocks, whatever happened to XSUNX which won awards in 2006, (or was it 2005) and was highly touted by a number of newsletters?

Haven’t heard anything in over a year, after a brief run, the share price sank back to where it was originally touted fir a considerable period! Was it one of those “pump and dump” stocks or did its technology not live up to the original hype. TAKING PROFITS!

Stlvelvet
Guest
0
Stlvelvet
April 28, 2008 4:35 pm

XsunX – My shares are down about 60%. I’m learning. They have sub-leased a facility (4/3/08) in Wood Village east of Portland, apparently from another down and out tech company. Mfg. is supposed to start by fall 08. One of their press releases indicate that they have orders for approx 1 years anticipated production. Since the stock has reciently gone up a couple or three cents, I guess I’ll hang in there and see what happens.

Mike
Guest
0
Mike
May 4, 2008 10:36 am

I have to check out this one but I have had a great run with SOL…check the PE and guidance on this. Has pulled back into the 15.50 -16 range from 18.50…I got in at 12. Solar has been on fire but if Oil comes down they all take a hit. I play the cycles and another Company to watch is YGE. Made money on that one too. Bought after a big dip and sold after a nice run

Lenny A
Guest
0
October 14, 2008 5:10 am
Thanks for your great advice on SPWR(a) that I took at close to $60/share days ago, as well as STP. I initially took an immediate loss the next day, but yesterday these stocks “popped” nicely. If/when the Russia-Iran-Venezuela Anti-American Alliance uses their “OIL WEAPON” by cutting off supplies to the western powers trying to recover from the global financial & credit crisis/meltdown, I can see numerous alternative energy stocks rocketing at daily multiples the financial investor heavens overnight… I really like stocks such as SPWRA, SE, DO, KYE, JRCC, CNX, CHK, XTO, BTU, CLNE, (OEGY penny stock) etc… (especially ZN… Read more »
who noze
Guest
0
February 23, 2009 6:20 am

xsnx runing out of money may have orders but they ant producing anything

wpDiscuz