written by reader Technical analysis

By hipockets, October 26, 2014

TECHNICAL ANALYSIS OF THE FINANCIAL MARKETS was mentioned weeks ago by another Irregular as an excellent reference for technical analysis (TA). ( I apologize for not being able to give him credit, but I could not find his name by searching SGS.) I bought the book because of his recommendation and because the book has 4 1/2 stars (out of 5) on Amazon. After starting to study it, I realized that reviewing the book might be a way to say “Thank You” to the Irregulars who are teaching me so much. I hope everybody finds this useful. If you don’t, you can complain to our CEO! :)

Before I get started – Joe, I was very disappointed when I found that Marxism was never mentioned. Not once! :)

The book was written by John H. Murphy; Revised 1999; New York Institute of Finance; IBSN 0-7352-006-1. Amazon’s price for a new book is about $55. Used books, as of today’s date, are available for between $25 and $30. The book has 542 pages, 19 chapters, and 4 appendices, all of which are listed at the end of this review.

To briefly sum up this review: I am glad that I bought the book. I have started using some of the techniques, and I’m convinced that it was money well spent. However, one wishing to learn TA cannot expect to read the book once and then magically be able to read charts. There must be a willingness to study the techniques and perhaps read some of the chapters more than once. Murphy says repeatedly that that the ability of analyze charts comes only with experience. TA is not a Holy Grail for guaranteeing stock performance, but I believe it has its uses.

The first edition, published in 1986, was TECHNICAL ANALYSIS OF THE FUTURES MARKETS. Although it did not specifically talk about stocks, many of the techniques can be used for either one. This second edition, published in 1999, contains much of the information from the first one, but there is much new information and the emphasis, of course, is on stocks. The differences between TA for futures and TA for stocks are well explained.

To benefit readers new to TA, one sentence from Chapter 5, and one from Chapter 6, might have been better placed early in Chapter 1. From Chapter 5: “The analyst must face the realization that he or she is dealing with percentages and probabilities. . . .” From Chapter 6: “The treatment of all chart patterns deals of necessity with general tendencies as opposed to rigid rules”.

The Good: A lot.

>> Murphy discusses many of the popular TA techniques in easy to understand language (usually, anyway, see the comment about “Elliot Wave Theory” below). Investors with no or little knowledge of TA and wanting to learn will find it invaluable. Investors who already use TA will probably learn additional techniques and at a minimum learn some nuances and variations of the techniques that they already use. There is a plethora of easy-to-read charts illustrating the techniques (easy to read except for some “Point and Figure” charts, see below), with explanations under each chart. The text font is large and easy to read.

The Bad: Not much. A few brabbles, just to be picky:

>> I earlier stated that the charts are easy to read. An exception: some of the ”Point and Figure” charts used a small font in order to pack as much data into the chart as possible. Sometimes the font size was so small that I had to use a magnifying glass.

>> I would like to have several practice charts at the end of most chapters with the question: “What is this chart telling us, and why?”

>> I would like to have a chapter on “Risk Analysis”, but since the risk would vary according to the expertise of the chart reader, I suppose such a chapter would not be possible.

>> I would like to have some discussion about the frequency of techniques occurring, e.g., “A head and shoulders pattern occurs roughly ”X” % of the time”. I would like it, but it probably can’t be done, once again due to the expertise of the chart reader. You might recognize a head and shoulders pattern, but I might not see any pattern at all.

>> The biggest complaint that I have is that Chapter 15, “Computers and Trading Systems”, says very little about software packages for PCs, although “Trade Station” is mentioned in the Chapter and later in Appendix C. I download end-of-day data daily and update my charts manually; I was hoping to find a review of some low cost software packages that would automate the procedure.

This is not a criticism of the book, but I feel that TA often would be of little use in working with microcaps. TA uses as its basis the buying and selling actions (derived from sales price and volumes) of shareholders. My thinking: The fewer the shares, the more the actions (warranted or otherwise) of a small number of shareholders can almost instantaneously affect the price. Conversely, I think TA would be of great benefit when investing in behemoths like JNJ.

Whole chapters are devoted to the basic concepts of many of the techniques. Murphy does not dive deeply into some of the topics, since some, such as Japanese Candlesticks and Elliot Wave Theory, have had whole books written about them. He lists several resources for such topics in one of the appendices.

After explaining the basics of a technique, he frequently writes about or mentions variations of the technique. When explaining RSI, “While 9 and 14 day spans are the most common values used…..some use shorter lengths, such as 5 or 7 days, to increase volatility….[or] 21 or 58 days to smooth out the RSI signals.” Also, he frequently mentions ways to confirm a signal. Many variations of moving averages are discussed.

Chapter 1 starts with a definition: “TA is the study of market action, primarily through the use of charts, for the purpose of forecasting future price trends”. It then lists the three basic assumptions of TA:
1. Market action discounts everything.
2. Prices move in trends.
3. History repeats itself.

(I think “History can repeat itself” or “History often repeats itself ” is more likely. :) )

There is a discussion about the differences between fundamental analysis and TA. Murphy says that, in essence, the fundamentals of a stock are built into the chart. “The fundamentalist studies the cause of market movement, while the technician studies the effect.” Later in the book, he says that charts are often leading indicators of changes in fundamentals and gives a few examples.

Chapter 13, which discusses Elliot Wave analysis, is hard for me to understand, although it seems to me to be a souped-up (I checked the spelling! :) ) version of moving averages. The basic theory is well explained—price movements come in 5 advancement (up) waves and 3 correction (down) waves. Then there are 9 different levels of magnitude. Etc. There are several explanatory charts — the thing that eludes me is how to easily apply the technique to buying/selling a stock. Since I am new to charting, and since this is a complicated topic, I will wait till I master the simpler techniques before getting into this one.

Gumlandians probably will not use the concepts of time cycles (Chapter 14) unless they are long-term investors, but it’s interesting to read about them. “. . . 37 different examples of the 9.6 year cycle, including caterpillar abundance in New Jersey, coyote abundance in Canada, wheat acreage in the U.S., and cotton prices in the U.S. . . . acted in synchrony ; that is, they turned at the same time. . . .” Seasonal cycles, typical stock market cycles, and the January Barometer are some of the topics worth reading.

Chapter 18 discusses evaluating the market as a whole and why it is important. Techniques such as the Advance-Decline Line and the McClellan Oscillator are discussed, and I found the information about comparing the various market averages very educational. If the comparison is to be meaningful, there is more to it than one would think.

Chapter 19 presents a 23 item check list that can be used when thinking about buying or selling. At first, I found the checklist to be intimidating, but after re-reading it, I saw that much of it would become second nature after understanding the techniques discussed in the previous chapters.

I will close by repeating the statement that “I’m glad that I bought the book”, and saying, “ Alan, I hope you were not overloaded with complaints! ”

Here’s the Table of Contents:

Chapter 1 Philosophy of Technical Analysis
Chapter 2 Dow Theory
Chapter 3 Chart Construction
Chapter 4 Basic Concepts of Trend
Chapter 5 Major Trend Reversals

Chapter 6 Continuation Patterns
Chapter 7 Volume and Open Interest
Chapter 8 Long Term Charts
Chapter 9 Moving Averages
Chapter 10 Oscillators and Contrary Opinion

Chapter 11 Point and Figure Charting
Chapter 12 Japanese Candlesticks
Chapter 13 Elliot Wave Theory
Chapter 14 Time Cycles
Chapter 15 Computers and Trading Systems

Chapter 16 Money Management and Trading Tactics
Chapter 17 The Link Between Stocks and Futures:
Intermarket Analasis
Chapter 18 Stock Market Indicators
Chapter 19 Putting It Altogether – A Checklist

Appendix A Advanced Technical Indicators
Appendix B Market Profile
Appendix C The Essentials of Building a Trading System
Appendix D Continuous Futures Contracts
Plus Glossary, Selected Bibliography, Selected Resources, and Index.

fini

This is a discussion topic or guest posting submitted by a Stock Gumshoe reader. The content has not been edited or reviewed by Stock Gumshoe, and any opinions expressed are those of the author alone.

432
Share your thoughts...

avatar
368 Comment threads
64 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
19 Comment authors
SoGiAmJohn KingHi PocketsJohn KingKennyG Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Leo Sullivan
Guest
Leo Sullivan

Thank you Hi pockets. Great synopsis. Tostart with i will buy the book. Piease excuse mylousy tablet typing.

eyedoc
Member
👍3556
eyedoc

Hi pockets, this was great work. I have looked at TA in the post and played for a few minutes with charts, but have never invested real money based on this discipline. If you are going to give chart lessons, I am open to learn.

Alan Harris
Guest
Alan Harris

Great starter HP. I think our problem is going to be finding a way to display graphic examples and our verbal descriptions may mangle the meaning. Has anyone got an idea for how we can draw and share pics so that everyone can view?

SoGiAm
Member
👍11466

Google Drive

Elliot
Member
👍502

Thanks for the post and the creation of the thread. I, too, have been working on my charting and I believe it can be useful in helping to choose entry and exit points, though it is certainly far from perfect. Is it too early to discuss what some of the best indicators might be? It seems everyone has their own favorites, and I must confess, there are some that I just ignore because I don’t really understand how to use them. My biggest gripe with charting is that it is basically looking back on what has happened and drawing conclusions… Read More »

sandiegojp
Member
👍491

Hello all. I’ve been studying Dr. Elder’s books. I have drawn a tree diagram based on his triple screen method. I don’t think I can attach it as a document hereto. Please let me know your email if you want a copy and I will forward it. I’m now studying Richard Wyckoff since I think a better way to play this game is to determine whether the institutions are buying and, according to what I’ve read so far, Wyckoff found out how to do this (note: this is what the Trading Academy peddles for many, many thousands of dollars). This… Read More »

Add a Topic
45
Travis Johnson, Stock Gumshoe
Admin
👍14988

Welcome, J-P — we don’t currently host images since that would slow down the site dramatically on the larger threads (maybe we’ll come up with a fast, safe and secure way to do this in the future, but don’t have one now), but if you’re able to post your documents publicly in Google Drive or Dropbox or some similar file sharing service (there are many free ones) you can post the link to those public files in comments here. That way you don’t have to give anyone your email address if you don’t want to. Thanks for contributing!

Add a Topic
4609
lskulow
Member
👍70
lskulow

JP, I agree on following the institutional buying/selling but have a hard time finding up-to-date information. I can pull up individual stocks on my E-trade site under insider activity and it shows monthly share rotation. Have you or anyone else here found anywhere on the internet that actually shows relatively up-to-date daily buying/selling? Or is the only way to get this information through analyzing volume and accum/dist levels and sp movement?
Thanks for the excellent review, Hi-Pockets!

Add a Topic
5916
sandiegojp
Member
👍491

Hi Linda. I get reports 3X a day from this site: J3SG.com.
It allegedly reports sales and purchases from insiders. Other than that, no. Lately, I’ve been reading up on Larry Williams’ Commitment of Traders report and trying to see if it does, as he claims, provides a “heads-up” or advance notice of the likely/probably direction of prices. I plan on giving a summary here later today.

EricS
Guest
EricS

Hi Pockets

Thanks for sharing. I’ll be a learning participant as you and Jean-Pierre guide us on this journey.
Per Alan’s comment, one may try useing the app, “Skitch” to create/draw charts.

Jean-Pierre knowing what and when institutions are buying/selling certainly seems like an ibdicator that could warrant further study.

sandiegojp
Member
👍491

As flattered as I am, I’m not sure I should be “guiding” anyone. If anything, I am myself looking for a “guide.” Happy to provide synopses of what I read though, along with my thoughts.

arch1
Member
👍7795

HP I give you credit for taking on a daunting task. I probably won,t follow much for so much involves driving by looking in a rear view mirror,,so to speak. Market direction ,volatility, sentiment and such may all be charted but the minute world news changes, a new discovery made a multitude of seeming unrelated things occur the model you may have crafted,crashes. At basis charting is giving a visual image of number crunching and is why it is so popular now with computers readily and cheaply available. If you think about it all you are doing is setting up… Read More »

arch1
Member
👍7795

Here is a link to a chart. Would you be willing to analyze and give opinion on what happens when FED stops QE?

https://mail.google.com/mail/u/0/?shva=1#inbox/1495874b95f796d4

dogg
Member
👍107
dogg

| What do these icons mean? dogg says: October 29, 2014 at 11:20 am Hi Pockets, Tough question. I usually look at the chart. If the uptrend is broken I do not give it much room. Look at GILD. When it hit 108 it ran out of steam. Nice rolling top. I meant to sell half but listened to everyone saying how great the company is and hesitated. When it broke 100 I sold. It bottomed at 91 and I reentered at 94. Sold again yesterday before earnings at 113 and bought again after hours at 109. Now I will… Read More »

Add a Topic
540
Lulu
Member
👍1300

Author: Alan Harris Comment: Er!!!! Lulu….see you on http://www.stockgumshoe.com/2014/10/microblog-technical-analysis/ The point is, us tec’s that are hanging on your every word (like me) will miss these shafts of light from your grey cells in a nano seconds time and not be able to refer back. Those 100’s that dont give a fig for technical’s, are having their inbox cluttered up with ‘yawn’ stuff. Woof Woof! Im just trying to keep the train of thought directed….nothing personal…honest guv. Dear Allan, Im the first to admit….I don’t understand much of anything here at Gumshoe and maybe Im too stupid and shud just… Read More »

arch1
Member
👍7795

Lulu Don’t take Alan too seriously, he may bark but he doesn’t bite. Here is a link where you can ask anything or just go and rant if you wish, Thats what is was set up for.

http://www.stockgumshoe.com/2014/07/microblog-politics-rights-religion-sex-and-investing-other-unmentionable-subjects

Where we are now has just been setup for questions/ideas on chart reading /tech
analysis and etc. Travis owns gumshoe and if he lets you post you are ok.

sandiegojp
Member
👍491

Hello everyone. So, I’ve been following Larry Williams who claims to have been trading for over 40 years and now ‘teaches’ others his techniques. Recently (like today), he blogged about how he uses the Commitment of Traders (COT) report to get advance notice of the likely/probable way the price will move. he claims to have developed an index (probably an EMA) tied to the COT to do this. He gives a couple of examples and even includes one where he just gives you the index and asks you pick the direction of the price. Then he shows you the chart.… Read More »

Elliot
Member
👍502

Hi Guys, I think Clovis Oncology (CLVS) is a good one to watch here … it’s been on a tear, up 40% since I bought in and has been making major breakouts lately. One last real resistance level is apparent to me, at it seems to be right where the stock is trading right now – around 61 – 62. If it breaks this, it could be off to test former highs. If it can’t break it, it may come down to touch the previous wedge resistance or one of the major moving averages such as the 20 day or… Read More »

Add a Topic
5971