What’s the Motley Fool’s “Holy Grail investment into ‘Oil Boom 2.0?'”

Checking out the latest "Welcome to Saudi America" pick teased by Motley Fool Stock Advisor

By Travis Johnson, Stock Gumshoe, October 24, 2014

The carnage in energy and oil services stocks over the last six months or so is causing a lot of contrarian investors to sit up and take notice — the combination of lower perceived demand (because of efficiency, slower growth in China, and the recession in Europe) and increased supply (because of the huge shale fields in the US, among other discoveries) is wreaking havoc… as many of us have seen in our portfolios.

But while West Texas crude has fallen perhaps 20% or so from the recent highs, the stocks of oil companies and oil services firms have fallen in some cases by 40% or 50% or more. So does that represent opportunity?

Maybe so. If that makes sense to you, and you don’t expect oil to fall to $50 or below, then you’re probably sniffing around for opportunities in the oil patch. The Motley Fool is here to oblige with a teaser pitch that will grab the eye of any energy investor… so I’ll sift through the clues and identify the stock for you, and you can let me know whether it’s a fit for your portfolio.

Here’s how the Fool introduces their latest pitch, which is aimed at grabbing new subscribers for the Gardner brothers’ flagship Stock Advisor newsletter:

“Imagine being among the first investors to stake a claim in the fast-emerging megatrend oil barons are already touting…

“‘As significant as the discovery of oil itself!’ ….

And the ad catches our eye with the riches enjoyed by some of the folks who are profiting from this boom — with the implication, to this Gumshoe’s ears, that investors will profit similarly if they follow the Gardner brothers’ advice. Here’s the example they start with:

“Last month, a six-figure check carefully addressed to Richard Dockery arrived in the mailbox outside his brand-new, 2,400-square-foot home.

“This wasn’t the first check of this size that he’d received. And it certainly won’t be the last…

“In fact, these checks arrive every single month like clockwork….

Are you getting our free Daily Update
"reveal" emails? If not,
just click here...


“My friend, I’m talking about millions upon millions of dollars in annual income here. The kind of wealth that ordinary folks like you and me are usually only allowed to dream about….

“… traces Dockery’s newfound riches all the way back to an emerging U.S. megatrend already being tabbed ‘Oil Boom 2.0’ by energy colossus BP.

“And it has everybody from hotshot oil bigwigs to generally poker-faced investment websites to the world’s greatest investor at a FEVER PITCH….”

So that’s true — this Dockery guy really is getting huge checks in his mailbox, and it really is from this “Oil Boom 2.0” … but that’s because he’s a real estate broker who lives in the middle of the Eagle Ford in Texas, and he rents land to some work camps and water drillers and also bought into some wells to receive royalties.

Oil is big, discoveries generate windfalls for people who are lucky, prescient, or smart about getting in on the discovery early… so there are obviously lots of people getting wealthy in the Eagle Ford, and the Permian Basin, and the Bakken (and a lot of people getting the shaft in these towns, too — imagine living on a teacher’s salary and not owning land when oil millions come to town and your rent triples). The Dockery story is from an article that ran in USA Today back in January, if you want to check i tout.

But the Motley Fool is not telling you to move to Midland, Texas, or any other boomtown, they’re just painting the picture of how much wealth is being generated… so you’ll be enticed to get on board with whatever their strategy is for generating oil wealth.

Got it? So what is their strategy? As you can imagine, it’s buying some kind of oil stock. For which one, let’s check the clues (and further enticements) they provide:

“… what is the point of telling you about all of the people making money here if I’m not going to give YOU a chance to join them?

“Still dubious? That’s okay… I’m not writing to cynics today. I’m writing to keen, forward-looking investors aspiring to fulfill the American Dream just like Richard Dockery did….

“All it will take from you is a dash of daring… and perhaps taking a few small steps outside of your usual comfort zone.

“Here’s how we’re going to do it…

“After hours upon hours of tireless research, two of the most brilliant investors I’ve ever met recently uncovered a surprising way for everyday folks like you and me to grab OUR fair share of this fast-emerging megatrend.”

Those “brilliant investors” are, of course, Dave and Tom Gardner, the brothers who founded the Motley Fool as an AOL chatroom and rode to fame on the back of the internet boom in the 1990s. And they have, indeed, put together a very good long term record at Motley Fool Stock Advisor (though that does not mean, of course, that they always pick good stocks or delight everyone — they also tend to be extremely long-term holders, holding through huge swoons, and that makes a lot of readers mad even if many of those stocks do eventually recover).

And the “surprising way” they’ve found for you to ride this “fast-emerging megatrend?”

Well, they run through a long exposition about the fact that there is a ton of oil buried in shale formations that hasn’t yet been found, that hydraulic fracturing opened them up to this “revolution” thanks to the pioneering work of George Mitchell, and that most people still know nothing about this “Oil Boom 2.0”. You’re not in the “most people” camp, I imagine, since investors have been chattering about this at least since the first Bakken craze almost a decade ago, so we won’t dig through the details of that…. but we finally do get to the clues about what stock they pick:

“The Backdoor Holy Grail Investment into ‘Oil Boom 2.0’…
I can promise you up front that you WON’T have to pick up and move to anywhere else in the country…

Nor will you have to hop on a plane to visit North Dakota, Texas, or any of the other numerous shale sites buried throughout America…

“And here’s the best part. Unlike Richard Dockery and those 2,000 North Dakotans a year, you won’t even have to lease your land to be drilled on 24/7 by rabid oil companies.

“No gaping holes in the ground… no pungent oil smell… no ear-piercing drilling… and no strangers prowling about your home at all hours of the day.

“In fact, you won’t have to give up anything at all!

“Because what if I told you there is actually a quick and easy way to invest in EVERYTHING I’ve told you today about ‘Oil Boom 2.0’ – WITHOUT even having to invest in the drilling process itself?”

Ooh, ooh, what is it!?!?

“A single, under-the-radar company that has its hands tightly wrapped around both the hydraulic fracturing technology and know-how that has allowed this shale boom to take off in the first place.”

OK, so sounds like it’s some kind of oil service company — not an actual driller, probably. Some more clues?

“Legendary hedge fund manager and CNBC TV host Jim Cramer is also banging the desk on this company, saying…

    ‘When it comes to tech stocks in the oil patch, my view is that you need to look no further than XXX XXXX.’

    ‘The company has the best technology in the business. Including figuring out the best way to approach and design the process of hydraulic fracturing – the drilling technique that’s unlocked all the oil in the shale plays that I’m constantly talking about.’

“He even told their CEO, ‘In the sweet spot, everyone is turning to you….'”

“This company actually provides a series of vital shale-related services for Big Oil clients….

“A highly valuable business model based around three core services and… most important… minimal competition. As Morningstar puts it, their ‘Competitive position is so strong that they have no direct rivals.'”

Huh. Well, that’s a lot of clues and hints — so we can probably name the stock for you based on that info, but let’s check and see what the Foolies say about those three “core services” first…

“Business 1: Fluid Sampling

“… whenever a client of theirs thinks they’ve uncovered a new oil field, the first thing they do is grab the phone and dial up our “Holy Grail shale company”…

“Who then collects numerous fluid samples from the potential new oil field. And performs a complex analysis that tells their client not only whether the area is actually rich in oil… but also what quality of oil they can expect to find if they drill there.

“It’s like playing the lottery and being told the numbers beforehand!

“Just think about the disadvantage you’d be at as an oil driller that didn’t contract with our ‘Holy Grail shale company….'”

OK, that sounds pretty important. I’m not an oil expert, so I don’t know if there are lots of different competitors in this “fluid sample analysis” business — but it sounds like Morningstar thinks they’ve got a “moat” too, so that’s a solid endorsement.

More?

“Business 2: Oil Well Production Enhancement

“But here’s where their business really starts to get interesting. It’s what initially made me such a rabid believer in their forward-thinking sales strategy in the first place….

“they help the client squeeze as much oil out of the well as possible, before having to drill a new one (remember it costs $4 million!). This includes selling them high-priced fracking equipment, telling them how often to frac, and even providing clients with top-of-the-line imaging tools that map out the oil well.

“This company truly does sit dead center in the crossroads between shale plays and oil-drilling technology.”

And finally…

“Business 3: Intellectual Property

“As Morningstar puts it, they ‘Possess decades’ worth of geologic data accumulated from oil fields around the globe. The time and capital required to duplicate these databases, if possible, represent a nearly insurmountable obstacle for competitors.’

“And while those decades of experience are obviously great for our peace of mind, they also yield a surprising new business opportunity…

“You see, our ‘Holy Grail shale company’ smartly packages the war chest of data and intelligence they’ve gathered throughout the years from Businesses 1 and 2, and uses it as leverage to bring bigger and bigger clients to the table…

“It’s currently their smallest business, but it’s growing fast.”

And they include a chart of the stock’s movement, which is a nice final bit of confirmation that we can use to double check the answer from the Thinkolator.

So what’s the stock? This is, sez the Mighty Mighty Thinkolator, the $6 billion Dutch oil services company Core Laboratories (CLB).

Which is becoming a more interesting story, to be sure, now that the downdraft in oil stocks has it giving up all of its gains of the last 18 months or so.

Want some confirmation of the Thinkolator’s work? That quote from Mad Money is from October, 2013, when the stock was in the $160s… you can see the clip here if you like.

And the Morningstar quotes are from their analyst, including from this pretty thorough update they shared in June after the stock had taken a hit because of reduced guidance. You can see the analyst report that they shared publicly here.

Core is a pretty unique service/technology provider in oil services, and Morningstar says they’ve usually looked expensive because they have a far stronger market position than most and have not had the same amount of cyclicality in their business (despite the recent downturn apparently due, in part, to some disappointing or delayed orders on Gulf of Mexico work). That’s certainly the case today, they’re still trading at a trailing PE of 24 (forward PE of 20) even after the stock has fallen by about a third since peaking in April (at around $220).

So what do you need to know in determining whether or not to buy Core Labs? Well, you’d probably want to read up and understand their business better than I do at this point, but it is a large and well-established business that is in a pretty enviable position — they provide important services, but the cost of their service is not a major part of the cost for their customers (analysis and reservoir assessment can add value, but cost a lot less than moving big oil rigs around, drilling, buying access to land, etc.)… which should mean that their margins are not under a lot of pressure. And indeed, their profit margins have been generally climbing most years over the past decade, so that’s a good indication of a strong business.

And, yes, it has usually been pretty expensive — the trailing PE ratio for Core Laboratories has very rarely been down to 20 or below over the last couple decades (excepting the 2008-2009 crisis, when it did go below 10 for a bit), so on that metric the stock is pretty close to as cheap as it has been in at least three or four years. Return on Equity has likewise been fantastic and growing for several years, which further reinforces the fact that their services have been in demand and that they have good economies of scale to improve margins when revenues rise.

So the quick scan? Looks pretty good. But, of course, it has fallen from $220 to $136 in six months — so something’s wrong. It could easily be that some deepwater projects are going more slowly with the oil price falling and with oil companies consistently saying that they’ll cut back on exploration budgets, and certainly the price of oil has an impact on oil services stocks even if they’re not necessarily directly selling crude, but it could be something else, too.

I’d have to learn a lot more about them to be completely confident, particularly about how unique their service offerings really are (whether someone else could do the work) and what their exposure to deepwater, US shale, and international projects might be, and they are reporting their next quarter in just a week (on October 22), so changes to their guidance could easily move the shares dramatically again.

But a good company that generates this much cash at high margins for a very long time is worth a look when it gets down to a low valuation relative to its history… even if it’s not necessarily falling into the “cheap” pile yet. They have a great balance sheet, have done a bit of buying back stock, and have become a good dividend grower over the last four years (though the current yield is still low at 1.5% or so), so there aren’t a lot of red flags that jump out at me… as long as their revenues don’t fall off a cliff. I didn’t rush out and buy shares after sniffing around the stock today, and I’m already overweight in energy stocks in my portfolio (to my detriment), but I did jot down a note to remind me to check out their earnings release next week and see if I can learn some more about them in the interim.

It’s your money you’re investing, so it’s your call — interested in Core Labs? Let us know with a comment below.


Irregulars Quick Take Paid members get a quick summary of the stocks teased and our thoughts here. Join as a Stock Gumshoe Irregular today (already a member? Log in)

32
Share your thoughts...

avatar
16 Comment threads
16 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
25 Comment authors
Joan in HoustonDavidDDThomas KellyTravis Johnson, Stock GumshoeChris Walsh Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Jensen
Guest
Jensen

I purchased three energy stocks: Hydrogen Engine Center, Inc. (HYEG); American Power Groups, Inc. (APGI); and U.S. Geothermal (HTM). I’m about break-even on HYEG and down almost 50 % on APGI and HTM. I think that I need a new hobby.

Add a Topic
200
Fencer
Guest
Fencer

Like learning about stop losses?

anton669
Irregular
👍6

Good company, but perhaps in the energy/oil space other bargains look better . However CLB is going to the watch list :))

Quincy Adams
Guest
Quincy Adams

Anyone who bought the “Holy Grail” at 200-plus and just checked in on the stock price today must be saying “Holy…(something else). To be fair, Morningstar now puts the “fair value” at 196 and credits them for having the widest moat possible. On the other hand, if WTI goes to $75/bbl and stays there, many of the lesser-funded shale drillers are going to at least curtail spending and some or all of production. This may be baked into CLB’s price already. Or not.

Add a Topic
5971
Add a Topic
1823
biggdan
Member
👍62
biggdan

Speaking if the Holy Grail, there are three important questions: 1. What is your quest? 2. What is your favorite color? 3. Where is the bottom for oil?

Add a Topic
359
jonomalley
Member
👍87

Red. No blue.

Michael Hughson
Guest
Michael Hughson

African or European oil?

Add a Topic
359
Steve
Guest
Steve

All I know is what I read online but I read elsewhere today that these shale drillers make money at $50 a barrel?. If true, they’re stil in good shape.

quincy adams
Guest
quincy adams

You may want to read businessweek.com article “U.S. Oil Producers May Drill Themselves into Oblivion” 10/13/14. In it they cited that Goldman Sachs estimated in July that U.S. shale producers needed $85/bbl to break even.

Add a Topic
359
Add a Topic
211
Gui_
Guest
Will

There’s a helpful chart in the following link showing the break even price for the different shale basins and co.s in those basins. Click on the chart to enlarge.
Shale Basin Breakeven Prices – Business Insider
http://www.businessinsider.com/shale-basin-breakeven-prices-2014-10?nr_email_referer=1&utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_term=Markets%20Chart%20Of%20The%20Day&utm_campaign=Post%20Blast%20%28moneygame%29%3A%20Here%20Are%20The%20Breakeven%20Oil%20Prices%20For%20America%27s%20Shale%20Basins&utm_content=COTD

barndoor
Member
👍18
barndoor

MF have liked this since ~$200/ ~April
The December $125 puts look pretty ripe to sell–waiting for report next week am I.

ivinghoe
Member
👍0
ivinghoe

Would think that SLB is a better bet going forward. And MF was pitching this three weeks ago.

jimrr
Guest

Saudi Arabia just slashed the price of their oil, didn’t anyone hear that one? They are also financing huge legal battles to stop fracking here. Does anyone REALLY know how much it costs to get a gallon to the pump?

Add a Topic
359
Add a Topic
2771
john
Guest
john

Very good company,but most can;t afford to invest enough in a $135 stock!

Add a Topic
5971
Deborah G Flynn
Guest

I feel the same way. I have plenty of other options to get nice growth and dividends. If I own a stock and it gets to $90-100 Great but I usually don’t buy them that high. I’m still watching a few of the rigs companies like Seadrill and Rig . Wonder if they have bottomed? Big dividends a lot of risk?

Add a Topic
570
Add a Topic
152
Add a Topic
5971
canonfodder
Member
👍82
canonfodder

CLB sounds quite interesting but I don’t have much cash in my portfolio and almost every stock in my portfolio was recommended by one of the Motley Fools or Teeka Tiwary at MTI or the Cheap Investor and my portfolio is down by 23% or so. It makes one think that he should just put his money in a company that sells data on the internet. I mean one’s own company, not someone elses. Of course if you try selling pencils, someone will make a ballpoint pen and destroy your business. Perhaps I should just buy some gold and wait… Read more »

Add a Topic
5971
Add a Topic
210
FDR
Guest
FDR

Or maybe you should just buy more dollar, short gold and wait for the latter to die?

Add a Topic
899
Add a Topic
210
Joan in Houston
Guest
Joan in Houston

I subscribed to some Motley Fool stuff some years ago. To say that I was disappointed would be an understatement. I am sad to hear that you are down at all, Edward, much less 23%. OUCH!! In any case, I have learned NOT to subscribe to anything anymore.

Add a Topic
329
Kees55
Guest
Kees55

Check out CLB via finance.yahoo.com:
No insider buying, only selling.
Analist opinion: nothing notable

Increase in earnings??? Not impressive.
But who knows…it might come in future

FDR
Guest
FDR

But seriously, SLB and HAL might be safer bet than CLB. I would also bottom fish some TAN. Feeling more comfortable to hold TAN long term than any fossil fuel names. Oil is here to stay, just might be on decline real long term. Time has changed.

Add a Topic
359
777stock777
Member
👍45
777stock777

Saudi is flooding the market with cheap oil in an attempt to take back the market for themselves. Russia is being forced to sell their oil at a discount due to sanctions. Someone mentioned the shale drillers make a profit at $50 oil. That’s laughable, plus why ride stocks down as margins shrink anyway. Would not be in the energy sector unless you are quite good at dead cat bounces.

Add a Topic
359
Add a Topic
424
Add a Topic
359
John Huynh
Guest

Here is the oil extraction costs as per CNBC. They gave a range because each field has a different price per barrel:

Alaska $40
Canada $50-$100
No Dakota $40-$70
Texas $40-$80
Eagle $40-$70
Venezuela $30
Saudi Arabia $10
Brazil $70
Nigeria $20-$40

Add a Topic
359
Add a Topic
1515
Add a Topic
77
Ghebrel
Guest
Ghebrel

Thank you everyone and especial thanks to Travis for keeping the trails continue.

DavidDD
Guest
DavidDD

CLB has come up again in the MF letter, but this time around it is ­around 100$, has it bottomed you think ? Is the analysis the same a few months later ?