This article was originally published on August 29, 2023. The ad is circulating heavily again from the Motley Fool, so we’re re-posting it with some updates… the stock being teased is still close to where it was back in August.
The Motley Fool has pitched their flagship Stock Advisor newsletter with artificial intelligence (A.I.) teaser picks before, though those have almost always been thinly veiled pitches for the titans of AI — NVIDIA (NVDA), Alphabet (GOOG) and Meta (META), specifically, have been the focus of their “AI Disruption Playbook” for a long time.
But now the Canadian cousins are getting into the game, with something a bit smaller… here’s how the latest email pitch from Motley Fool Canada came in over the weekend, advertising their own version of Stock Advisor (C$99/first year, renews at C$199):
“This morning’s major AI stock alert….
“Insiders believe 2023 could be a “critical inflection point” for artificial intelligence…
“And this tidal wave of cash could be unleashed much sooner than you might think.
“After all, when ChatGPT was released last November, it reached a million users… in 5 DAYS!”
So what’s the “best way to get your cut” of this huge opportunity? They say, naturally, that it’s a “tiny stock” that you have to sign up to learn about… but they also drop some clues, so let’s see if we can get a name for you:
“I think you’ll want to hear about the tiny TSX-traded stock that the Motley Fool Canada team just published a detailed BUY report on.
“Because this AI-powered company is…
“Led by a savvy founder who personally owns over $54 million worth of shares
“Growing rapidly with revenue up 14x in the past 6 years
“Profitable and sitting on a war chest of cash with zero debt”
And they say that this “under-the-radar Canadian stock” is “650X smaller than NVIDIA” — which is a nonsensical claim, but presumably means that it’s about 1/650th the size of NVIDIA. That would put it in the $1-2 billion market cap range, most likely.
The final push from them:
“5 years from now, this tiny Canadian company could be the one A.I. stock you wished you had in your portfolio.”
So what’s the stock, and what’s the story? This is, sez Le Thinkolateur, the Canadian e-learning leader Docebo (DCBO in both Toronto and NY). They offer a platform for learning management for enterprises, basically a modern and cloud-based staff development and training system. Here’s how the company describes itself on its “why invest” page:
“Since our founding in 2005, we have seen significant changes in the way that enterprises approach learning. Corporate e-learning solutions were once considered a “nice-to-have”. However, in recent years, our customers have begun to recognize that corporate e-learning solutions are a core part of their strategy for success. We believe that corporate training and learning will continue to be an important challenge for businesses and we are committed to working with our customers to meet this challenge.
“Docebo initially launched as an open-source model that was installed directly on customer servers. In 2012, we made the transition to a cloud-based SaaS platform model, which is currently being offered to our customers. Our platform and related products are constantly evolving as we continue to embrace new technologies. For example, we were one of the first organizations to introduce artificial intelligence into the e-learning market by integrating artificial intelligence into our products. We believe that artificial intelligence is transforming corporate e-learning into a competitive advantage for enterprises since it allows enterprises to get data-driven insights so that they can enhance a learner’s experience and improve their workforces faster and more effectively. At Docebo, we have never stopped embracing new technologies as we seek to redefine the way that modern workforces learn.”
And it may indeed be that Motley Fool Canada has published a new report about this stock, or is somehow changing their thinking about it, and maybe it was even a new recommendation from this specific Stock Advisor Canada newsletter back in August, but this has also been one of the more enthusiastically covered stocks by the Canadian Fools over the past few years, and, judging by their past teasers and disclosures, it has been an official recommendation of at least one Fool newsletter since the Spring of 2021 (it was also around C$60 back then, though the stock rose later in 2021 and fell in 2022 like most of its tech stock compatriots).
So what’s the current situation? Docebo is indeed profitable, with a bit of a “war chest” and no debt, and they have had very good growth since 2016 (almost exactly 14x growth, in case you’re double-checking those clues). They’re also primarily bringing in recurring revenue — their annualized recurring revenue now stands at US$182 million (was $173 million in August), with growth recently at about 25%. Their net dollar retention rate in 2022 was 109%, which means that they kept 109% of their spending from existing customers — so customers are doing more upgrading of their Docebo installations than they are cutting back. They say their contracts have consistently gotten larger, and that most of their sales are of multi-year contracts, so there should be some stability to the business.
It’s barely profitable, to be fair — they haven’t burned much cash in building out the business, they have strong gross margins, and they have posted adjusted profits and an improving adjusted EBITDA margin for the past two years… including, they say, a “free cash flow margin” of 18% last quarter (16% last quarter), though it looks like a lot of that came from adjustments to working capital and stock-based compensation, along with some adjustments for their foreign exchange losses (presumably from fluctuation of the Canadian dollar versus the US$, since they earn most of their money in the US). All these numbers are from their latest investor presentation, on November 9, if you’d like to get a sense of how they’re selling themselves right now.
I can’t say that I have any great insight into Docebo or how it compares to other learning management/training platforms for (mostly) corporate education and development programs, but they have been showing good growth and they are at that attractive level where they’re just about to be consistently profitable, and that’s where the sometimes explosive-looking earnings growth often shows up in the numbers, which tends to attract investors.
"reveal" emails? If not,
just click here...
And they are genuinely using AI to build their training programs and help companies design effective learning systems for employees… though, again, I have no sense, qualitatively, of how effective that AI usage might be, or how much it will add to their bottom line over time. It’s obviously a wild stretch to put “could be the next NVIDIA” in their email subject lines for this teaser ad, they certainly don’t have any kind of huge embedded leadership in AI hardware or software right now, but they could benefit from better AI that leads to better learning management systems, and they claim to be an early adopter in the space.
Where will the stock go? Much will depend on how enthused the market is about SaaS companies with fairly steady growth — investors lusted after such firms back in 2021 and routinely paid 20-30X ARR for them during the boom, and the shine has come off to some degree, so the valuations still seem to be resetting.
Right now, Docebo says they have US$182 million in ARR, so at a $1.4 billion market cap they’re valued at about 8X ARR, and just under 9X trailing revenue. That sounds reasonably attractive for a small company that’s emerging into profitability and still growing quite rapidly. Analysts now believe they’ll be able to report about 83 cents (US$) in adjusted earnings next year (up from a 72-cent estimate six months ago), and investors are often willing to overlook stock-based compensation, particularly for smaller growth companies, so that would mean, at US$44, they’re currently trading at about 53X forward earnings, down from 60X back in August. With the expected near-term growth in earnings of about 50% per year, they could grow into that very quickly if the business continues to perform well — it’s a rich valuation, but they have also blown away the analyst earnings estimates for several quarters in a row, including a nice beat and raise back in August that helped lift the stock by about 30% (boosted by an announced deal to use Google Cloud’s Generative AI capabilities including a “Generative AI Learning Technology Hackathon” that probably boosted investor interest a bit), and a solid beat (with a much smaller “raise” for guidance) back in November… so it’s clearly a speculative idea, but not, to my eyes, a ridiculous one.
And if you were on the fence back in August and didn’t bite on the Fool’s recommendation… well, you didn’t miss much. It was around $43 then, it’s at about $44 today, and the valuation has gotten a little cheaper as expectations for 2024 earnings have bumped up a little bit.
It’s not my money on the line, though, it’s yours — so you get to make the call. Think 25% revenue growth and some emerging earnings growth that could be in the 50% range is worth a buy? See great things for learning management platforms in general, or for using AI for training and teaching in the future? Have any reason to like or loathe Docebo specifically? Please let us know with a comment below.
P.S. More AI? If you’re interested in the Motley Fool’s “A.I. Disruption Playbook” that has also been making the rounds, I covered that one back in November here, the ad is still circulating and unchanged… and the Fool has some other AI-focused teaser pitches rolling these days as well, including the “AI Inflection Point” about some “Rocket Fuel” AI Microcap stocks which I wrote about here, with a few new stocks to consider, and a similar “Microcap AI Sleeper Stocks” pitch which I covered a couple months ago, with slightly different stocks named. Docebo played at least a supporting role in most of those “small cap AI” pitches from Motley Fool Canada, so it seems to pretty consistently be their favorite teaser stock for AI mania (and was pitched by them pretty regularly before the AI craze really took off last year).
Disclosure: Of the companies mentioned above, I own shares of Google parent Alphabet and NVIDIA. I will not trade in any covered stock for at least three days after publication, per Stock Gumshoe’s trading rules.
soounds good!
Thanks for the info. I have a position in a small Canadian AI company that issued an interesting press release yesterday- Verses AI Inc. VRSSF on USA OTC, VERS on CBOE Global for Canadians.
Verses AI definitely got some of the AI-mania interest a few months ago, I covered it when Tobin Smith was pitching the stock but there was a lot of paid promotion going on for that one as well. Looks like the shares have come down to earth a bit, I haven’t looked at the financials since I wrote that article a couple months ago.
Travis, another VRSSF investor here. I got the stock after reading your rundown and summary and I’m delighted with it. Every intention of getting more.
Hope it works out for you… I’m still pretty skeptical about that one myself, but I certainly miss out on some speculative winners because of that skepticism.
Hello. Which brokerage are you trading this on? Thanks
My problem with Docebo is I don’t know if their product will become commoditized. If you have a topic you want to teach to a particular audience, can you use prompt-engineering to get AI to produce the lessons well enough? If you can’t do that now, what about in 3 years time, or 5 or 10 years? Maybe there’s a good reason why that isn’t a risk, that I don’t know about. I prefer businesses with proprietary information for training AI, and some semiconductor stocks e.g. Applied Materials.
Yeah this has been a constant bit of trouble for me to get past too, but then look at all the ridiculous AI based software programs that people have essentially built and then sold as ready made businesses or Apps, since ChatGPT and Open AI came out. For that matter it sort of makes one wonder why Microsoft paid all they did to update BING when the keys where in the car pretty much already for them to have their programmers tweak and rev-up the engine with another years data collection. ( I am kiddind- sort of) obviously they are all paying for the expediency factor. Time is money, or it seems to be in today’s world, where everything must move faster, store more info, or its lost to the every ready memory dump, or cache clearing.
Its been proven time and time again humans do not function optimally under these conditions, so even if a training program is more effective, I would seriously question what it is better at training them to Do? A very narrow scope job, where they have no autonomy, and must check with AI instead of Think Critically for themselves.
I for one am glad I will be getting to be an ‘old’ person before I have to guess what progress does to too much of the rest of the job scape, let alone investing lol
I stead of Artificial Intelligence, we should focus on Natural Stupidity.
It’s true, investors will likely profit more from avoiding stupidity than being super-brilliant.
Brilliant!! I am stealing that phrase!
I bought Docebo not long ago. It’s up 7.7%, including 1.89% today, at $45.72. However, I just checked the rating on Chaikin Analytics and see it has dropped from Bullish to Neutral+ due to the very poor financials, despite the very positive other categories.
That’s odd. Their financials have gotten better over the last six months, not worse. They’re not great, since they’re barely profitable and are spitting out a lot of stock-based compensation, but they’re not getting worse.
I fail to see the AI in DCBO and in many for that matter; to me, AI is a cool technology that is supposed to help in creating technology for example, NVIDIA gives you AI shovels so you can use them to create meaningful work. MSFT/ChatGPT, if worked properly would provide great service as well. This DCBO uses AI for their own training creation just the same way one would use AI to create a resume, nice, but that does not benefit me.
This sentence from Docebo’s “Why Invest” page makes very little sense. “We believe that artificial intelligence is transforming corporate e-learning into a competitive advantage for enterprises since it allows enterprises to get data-driven insights so that they can enhance a learner’s experience and improve their workforces faster and more effectively.”
The company is saying that AI allows enterprises to get data-driven insights. Somehow this is supposed to transform e-learning. Huh?
Why aren’t you looking at Poet Technologies?
For this article? Because it doesn’t match the clues at all.
In general? Mostly just because POET has been a “story stock” for a decade but hasn’t ever built into a real business, and I have no idea when or if they ever will. They have consistently created more new shares per year than they have generated dollars of revenue, for almost a decade.
I know there are plenty of fans of this stock out there, but it will probably remain outside my wheelhouse until they actually have some revenue. I don’t usually buy into R&D stories — I’m not an expert scientist or industry insider who can judge their value or their odds of success well enough to put money at risk, and betting on that as-yet unproven potential of a pre-commercial R&D program is just too speculative for my taste.